The necessary work to explain the rules
"Because I say so!", "When you get older you will understand!". Children of
yesterday and of today have all heard sentences of this kind. They seem
innocent, but they hide a useless aggressiveness. They put children in a
humiliating condition of intellectual inferiority. The reasons for a rule
are unclear and incomprehensible. It is in the long run harmful and
self-defeating. To give rules it is necessary to follow...rules. And the
first rule is never to forget that the objective of every scolding, of all
punishment, of all impositions has to be that of making the child understand
what he has done wrong, what rule has been broken, what the consequences of
his behavior can be. With the end objective being to give the child the
ability to distinguish, autonomously, the importance of values and shared
limits.
Don't be bad-mannered, don't approach strangers, don't do this, don't do
that. For a child it is difficult to understand the borders between what is
right and what is wrong and every imposition, every prohibition, is lived as
an action of enforcement and limitation put into action by the world of
adults. The passage to an awareness of the rules happens slowly, along a
route of successes and defeats, of clashes and mediations. A difficult
route. Difficult for a child, difficult for a mother and father. If this
wasn't the case the work of a parent would be much more simple. And this is
what we have to consider when we are about to forbid, to deny or to impose
something on our children.
Rules are of primary importance for the growth of a child: they help him
to start to understand reality, they contribute to forming his identity,
they make him feel safer. For this reason they cannot be "enigmatic". It is
true, it is not easy to educate a child. But fatigue, disappointment, even
the comprehensible apprehension in wanting to protect him from dangers
always have to leave room for reflection, for calm and objectivity. When
faced with the nth ill-mannered behavior, you should simply explain to the
child that social rules are consider inconvenient certain attitudes. Equally
when faced with a broken rule it is essential that the child understands
that the disappointment of his mother or his father is only due to their
desire to help him avoid making mistakes and to allow him to understand the
consequences of its behavior. Consequences that, therefore, must be
explained. Use simple words, in a clear way and try to give him reasons
which are as close as possib le to reality. There is no need to give
in-depth explanations that we consider inadequate for the age of the child
and that most probably would be totally incomprehensible to him. The
objective is simply to create a reference within the child, that gets him
used to autonomously considering matters that can or cannot be done, things
that can and cannot be said, things that can and cannot be dangerous.
"Because I say so" means, on the other hand and in any case, making sure the
child obeys the rule without nevertheless letting him confront himself with
it. It means, in short and metaphorically "eliminating the danger". But when
children grow up "the elimination of danger" must progressively be replaced
by an "education on danger". It is important that a child learns to
recognise the risks and the effects of an attitude, that he is informed
about the possible consequences and able to behave correctly. And, to do
this, children have to know and they have to be informed. "I have told you a
thousand times not to speak to strangers" "Why?" "You will understand when
you get older": it is a useless and self-defeating sentence that stems from
the comprehensible anxiety that overcomes us when, for instance, we see an
adult talking to our child. But is so much anxiety truly necessary? More
than an total and generic prohibition, isn't it better perhaps to provide a
precise and circumstantial explanation? A child cannot and must no grow up
with a fear of strangers, protected by a curtain of prohibitions and
denials. A child can and has to grow up by developing his own ability to
understand dangers, to appraise the limits of a normal relationship between
adults and children, to confront his parents with his own fears, his own
anxieties, his own experiences. But to achieve all this there has to be
dialogue and confidence between parents and children. "Because I say so!",
"When you get older you will understand!": are sentences that can achieve
fear and respect. But more is needed to grow up and gain self-independence.